Financing Available
(484) 602-6863
Valley Peak Roofing Logo

What Hail Damage Looks Like on a Roof, and When to Repair or Replace

Valley Peak Roofing Team Roof Repair
Aerial view of a brick house with hail damage across its asphalt shingle roof

Hail damage on asphalt shingles shows up as scattered dark spots where granules were knocked off, soft bruises you can feel, and cracked or torn shingles, usually with matching dents on gutters, vents, and flashing. Check what you can from the ground and leave the roof itself to a roofer. Scattered hits on a newer roof can often be repaired, while widespread damage on an older roof usually points to replacement.

What hail damage looks like on asphalt shingles

The Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety (IBHS), a nonprofit building research group, says real hail damage "occurs in a random pattern" and that a bruise "can usually be felt" on a real hail impact.

  • Bruises or soft spots. A hit can crush the shingle without breaking the surface. The spot gives when pressed, like a bruise on an apple.
  • Granule loss. Hail knocks off the sand-like granules and leaves dark, round spots of bare asphalt. Granules often pile up at the bottom of downspouts.
  • Exposed mat. A hard hit can break through the asphalt and expose the fiberglass mat underneath.
  • Cracked or torn shingles. IBHS found that dents, ridges, and tears are the shingle damage "most directly correlated to water penetration."
  • Damaged ridge caps. IBHS calls ridge caps "one of the most hail-vulnerable parts of a shingle roof."

Damage around the house that points to hail

IBHS says dents and spatter marks around the house are good signs hail fell, and to check them before judging the roof:

  • Dented gutters and downspouts
  • Dented roof vents, flashing, and chimney caps
  • Dented fins on the outdoor AC unit
  • Cracked or dented siding
  • Torn window screens
  • Spatter marks: clean, round spots on weathered metal where hail knocked the grime off

What is not hail damage

IBHS lists blisters, mechanical marks, manufacturer defects, and granule loss along shingle edges as common look-alikes.

What you seePoints to hailPoints to something else
PatternRandom hits across a slopeLines, one cluster, or only where people walk
FeelA soft spot at the hitHard, with no give
Granule lossRound spots, with dents on nearby metalEven wear along edges or across an aging roof
Bumps and pitsRound marks that match dents on gutters and ventsBlisters: raised bumps or popped pits, with no damage on nearby metal

Check from the ground, and stay off the roof

Do not climb on the roof to look for hail damage. Shingles can be slick after a storm, a fall from roof height is serious, and foot traffic leaves scuffs that look like hail.

  1. Walk the perimeter. Look for dented gutters and downspouts and for granule piles under downspout outlets.
  2. Check metal you can see: vents, flashing, the chimney cap, the AC unit, a mailbox or grill.
  3. Look at siding and windows, especially on the side the storm came from.
  4. Scan the roof with binoculars for missing or torn shingles, dark round spots, and ridge damage.
  5. Check the attic with a flashlight for wet or stained roof boards, and again after the next heavy rain.
  6. Photograph everything, with dates. The Pennsylvania Insurance Department says to take pictures or video of damage before you clean up or make repairs.

For a full walk-around list, use our post-storm roof inspection guide.

Hail size and what it typically does to a roof

The National Weather Service calls a thunderstorm severe when it produces hail at least 1 inch across, about quarter size. That is a sensible point to get a roof checked.

Hail sizeNWS comparisonWhat it means for asphalt shingles
Under 0.75 inchPea to marbleBelow severe, and well under the 1.5 inch size new shingles handled well in IBHS tests.
0.75 to 0.88 inchPenny to nickelStill below severe. The only hail reported in Lehigh or Northampton County from June through early September 2026 was this size.
1.00 inchQuarterThe NWS severe threshold. Check gutters, vents, and other soft metal.
1.25 inchesHalf dollarThe largest hail reported in either county since 2024 (Allentown, April 30, 2024).
1.50 inchesWalnut or ping pong ballIBHS says new shingles, impact-rated or standard, "should offer good protection" at this size and smaller when hail falls without strong wind.
1.75 to 2.00 inchesGolf ball to hen eggIn IBHS 2 inch tests, dents and ridges were the most common weak spot, and results varied widely between shingles.

Those IBHS tests used new shingles and hail falling straight down. An older roof or a windy storm falls outside them, so have an older roof checked after any quarter-size or larger hail.

Recent hail in Lehigh and Northampton counties

NOAA's Storm Events Database lists 11 hail reports in the two counties across 2024 and 2025, on four days, and none from January through May 2026.

  • April 30, 2024. A trained spotter reported hail up to 1.25 inches, half-dollar size, in Allentown from 7:52 to 7:56 pm. One-inch hail fell in Fullerton, Slatington, Stiles, and Balliettsville, and North Catasauqua had "sixteen minutes of dime to quarter sized hail."
  • May 6, 2025. Some 1-inch hail near Shoenersville.
  • July 3, 2025. One-inch hail near Steel City in Northampton County.
  • Summer 2026. Preliminary National Weather Service reports show only nickel-size hail, near Wescosville on July 28.

Hail damage does not always leak right away. If your roof went through the April 2024 storm and nobody has looked at it, get it inspected before snow season.

Repair or replace: how to decide

It comes down to how much of the roof was hit, how old it is, whether new shingles will match, and what your insurance approves.

FactorLeans toward repairLeans toward replacement
How much was hitA few hits on one slopeHits across several slopes, or many cracked shingles
Roof ageNewer roof, flexible shinglesOlder roof, brittle shingles, or wear from before the storm
MatchingSame shingle and color still madeDiscontinued line or faded color
UnderneathDry, solid roof deckSoft or stained decking, or leaks inside
InsuranceAdjuster approves a spot repairAdjuster approves a slope or the full roof

Roof age affects the payout too. The Pennsylvania Insurance Department's example: a 17-year-old roof with a 20-year warranty would see depreciation "for the age and condition of the roof" under actual cash value coverage. Check whether your policy pays replacement cost or actual cash value.

Matching is the hard part of a repair. Shingle lines get discontinued and colors weather, so ask whether your shingle is still made before planning a patch. How a policy handles mismatched shingles varies, so ask your adjuster.

What a hail repair involves

A proper hail repair replaces the damaged shingles instead of dabbing sealant on each bruise. The roofer lifts the shingles above, pulls the damaged one and its nails, slides in a new shingle, nails it, and reseals the tabs. Damaged ridge caps, vents, and flashing get replaced too. See our residential roof repairs.

When the damage is too widespread for a repair, the answer is roof replacement. IBHS advises choosing roofing with a Class 4 impact rating under UL 2218 or FM 4473 when you replace or repair a roof covering.

Insurance and next steps

The Pennsylvania Insurance Department lists "windstorm or hail" as a covered peril even on the most basic homeowners form. It says to take photos before cleanup and "don't make permanent repairs until your insurance company approves them." Temporary fixes that stop more damage are fine. It also warns: "Be wary of anyone who knocks at your door, including contractors and public adjusters."

For the full claim process, from notifying your insurer to the adjuster visit and final payment, see our Pennsylvania storm damage insurance claim guide.

Get a roofer's eyes on it

If you found dents, granule piles, or dark spots, the next step is an up-close inspection. Valley Peak Roofing Co. is based in Bethlehem, PA and inspects hail-damaged roofs across Lehigh and Northampton counties. We are GAF Certified, PA HIC PA171080. Contact us to schedule an inspection.

Frequently Asked Questions

How can you tell if your roof has hail damage?

Start on the ground. Dented gutters, downspouts, vents, and AC fins, plus granules piled at downspout outlets, are strong signs of hail. On the roof, hail leaves random dark spots, soft bruises, and cracked or torn shingles. Confirming shingle damage takes a roofer on the roof, so do not climb up yourself.

What does minor hail damage look like on a roof?

Usually a scatter of small dark spots where granules are missing, with little or no cracking. It can be invisible from the ground. The shingle may feel soft at the hit, which is how a roofer tells a bruise from normal wear. It is still worth documenting, because hail can shorten the life of a roof.

How big does hail have to be to damage a roof?

The National Weather Service calls hail severe at 1 inch, about quarter size, and that is a sensible point to get a roof checked. In IBHS tests, new asphalt shingles held up well against hail 1.5 inches and smaller falling without strong wind. Older shingles and wind-driven hail were not part of those tests.

Can hail damage on a roof be repaired?

Yes, when the damage is limited. A roofer replaces the damaged shingles, ridge caps, vents, or flashing rather than sealing over bruises. Repairs work best on a newer roof where matching shingles are still made. When hits cover several slopes or the roof is already old, replacement usually makes more sense.

How bad does hail damage have to be to replace a roof?

There is no single number. Replacement makes sense when hits cover several slopes, many shingles are cracked or torn, the roof was already near the end of its life, or matching shingles are no longer made. The adjuster's scope matters too, since some claims approve a full roof and others only spot repairs.

How long can a roof last after hail damage?

It depends on how hard it was hit. IBHS notes that hail can damage roof coverings and shorten the life of a roof, and it ties cracks, dents, and tears most directly to leaks. If hail hit your roof, have it inspected instead of waiting for a leak to show up.

Sources

Found Signs of Hail Damage?

Valley Peak Roofing inspects hail-damaged roofs across the Lehigh Valley and gives you a straight answer on repair or replacement. Call (484) 602-6863 or schedule an inspection online.

Schedule an Inspection

Share This Article

FINANCING AVAILABLE!

On a Budget? We've Got You Covered!

Learn More

Quality Roofing at a Price You Can Afford.

Use our cost calculator to estimate your roofing project budget.

Cost Calculator

Schedule Your Free Hail Damage Inspection Today!

Let us provide you with a strong, long-lasting roof replacement that enhances your home's safety and value!

VALLEY PEAK ROOFING CO

Your Free Estimate Form

WHY CHOOSE US?

Hail Damage Recovery Experts

  • Certified Hail Damage Assessment
  • Storm Damage Documentation
  • Fast Storm Damage Repairs
  • Documentation for Claims
  • Written Estimates for Your Insurer

When hail strikes in Pennsylvania, Valley Peak Roofing responds quickly. We help homeowners navigate the insurance process, document damage properly, and restore roofs to pre-storm condition. Trust our experience to make your hail damage recovery smooth and stress-free.

Our Services

About Us